+27 53 927 3938
71 De Kock Street

3 Bennie's Story


The tragic story of the 3 Bennies

This is the story as told by Joachim Scholtz, who was also in the accident.

"On this day - I think it was May 1947 - I was in matric then, four school rugby teams would have played at Christiana . The late Oom George van der Linde would transport us with a 5-ton truck that served in the Second World War as a troop carrier. Since everyone couldn't sit on the steel benches, the three Bennies and Mr. S. M. de Villiers sat on the truck’s tailgate. We would drive across Schweizer-Reneke and Bloemhof.

We had to cross the railway line at Ferndale - between Bloemhof and Christiana. We had to go through the gates on either side of the track to get over the track. Someone with a donkey cart opened the gates. Since the truck had a canvas as a roof, the vast majority couldn't see the outside. The station (siding) was densely overgrown with large trees. When the uncle turned to the gate, one of the Bennies peered out and shouted to us inside, "You who come out of the Kalahari and haven't seen a train yet. Look, there is one now.” (From Christiana) Of course, only the three Bennies and Mr. SM De Villiers (and I) saw the train. I just sat behind the cab and as there was an opening, I peeked out and saw the train coming on the other side of the siding. Uncle George drove through, because the gates were open. Here I have to say that the windows were turned up and that the mica was yellow and cracked between the windows, which obstructed the sight.

I don't know if the locomotive blew the whistle at the transition - I didn't hear anything. Maybe the Uncle didn't hear anything either. Nonetheless - when the front wheels were between the tracks, the train hit the truck's cab - this I saw through the opening between the sail and the cab. The train was at full speed and swung  the truck around so that the three Bennies were thrown against the locomotive. They had no chance and died instantly. Mr. SM de Villiers fell off. The wheels of the truck lay 72 feet (±23 meters) away. The other occupants flew through the canvas and some landed inside the trucks and others landed between the trucks and were dragged along.

Mr. Van der Linde died in his son's arms. I had a miraculous escape. I fell along the railway line, so close that the wheels tore my pants and jacket off my body. My hat was attached to the jacket's lap with a string and it was also torn away. I kept these clothes for many years. The only injury I sustained was a cut on my wrist. I later had to undergo a back operation and an operation on my hand.

To continue. When I got up, Mr. SM de Villiers already established order. It was a terrible sight to see more than fifty people lie - some seriously injured. There was no phone on the station and the first car to go and call for help arrived after about half an hour . Ambulances came from Vryburg, Schweizer and Wolmaransstad. A special train with doctors and nurses was hurriedly sent from Kimberley to transport the seriously injured to Klerksdorp Hospital. Among them was Mr. Calitz and Mr. Klue (two of the teachers who sat in the front). In Vryburg Hospital, 24 injured were treated.”

The three Bennies:

Bennie Kruger (Matric)

Bennie Kühn (Std. 9)

Bennie van Niekerk (Std. 8)

The 3 Bennies remembered

Every year in May VHS lays a flower wreath at the Three Bennie Monument on the school grounds. This commemorates the gruesome bus accident of 71 years ago, in which the three sons, Ben Cühn, Bennie van Niekerk and Bennie Kruger died on May 3, 1947. The impact of this on VHS was so great that these people's memory today is still honoured by an annual wreath at the monument, and the school's highest award are named after these three boys. The Three Bennie Trophy is awarded each year to the most versatile matric learner. Hereby VHS also shows our gratitude to the Heavenly Father for every other child who, over the past 71 years, has safely gotten off the bus after sports matches.